
Written by Alpha Digital Agency· · Updated
Choosing a Bali agency for hotels and villas through seven transparency proofs
Seven criteria for comparing Bali agencies for hotels and villas, from reservation definition and data access to transaction testing and handover.
When requesting a proposal, submit one problem that the property is currently facing. For example, advertising expenses appear in the monthly report, but the number of guests from the website is difficult to match with the arrival list. Ask each prospective agency to show the data to be requested, the jobs that come in the offer, as well as examples of the form of decisions after the examination. The answers can be compared even though each uses different terms. For the initial session, create an example of a fictitious transaction and cover the guest's identity.
The first evidence is in the form of the agreed reservation definition
Before looking at the chart, give the candidate an example pair. The first is a prospective guest who presses the WhatsApp button to ask about the price. The second is a guest with a reference number and a payment confirmation that can still be cancelled. Ask the candidate to explain how both of these activities appear in the report. Add the condition when the guest actually arrives. The usable answer will mention the source of the record, who updated the status, and when the number may be considered final.
Turn that answer into a short metrics dictionary. Write down what is counted as question, transaction, confirmed reservation, and overnight stay. If the property manages multiple villas, tell which team is responsible for fixing an incorrect status. Test the definition on one case of a partially cancelled deposit payment. Reception and finance need to produce consistent classification before the numbers are used to compare channels or evaluate agency performance.
Second evidence in the form of access to reports and change history
Request a report without client information. Choose one number and ask the candidate to demonstrate how to trace it to the source. Ask whether the account is property-managed, who holds administrative access, how access is revoked when staff move, and who approves changes to tracking. Request a report version that remains readable when vendor access stops. Dashboard design becomes less important if the hotel struggles to reconstruct what changed during a specific month.
Simulate a meeting when two different numbers appear on the screen. The reservation team uses the check-in date while the digital team uses the transaction date. Ask the candidate to demonstrate both filters and write down their consequences in the report notes. Find the answer that distinguishes data correction from target revision. If changing the definition is necessary, set the start date and ensure the numbers before and after the change have descriptions that the owner can understand.
The third evidence is in the form of repeatable event testing
Ask the candidate to show a purchase testing plan. Ask when the event is sent, how to connect it back to the transaction, and how to prevent misreading when the visitor reloads the success page. Value and currency must be meaningful to the finance department. If payment is not completed, the report should allow the team to trace until which stage the test is ongoing. Google Analytics ecommerce guide
An Alpha team inspection note on hospitality property measurements in Bali shows why this question is worth asking. The team sees Purchase coming in, while the key event uses purchase. That spelling difference limits the interpretation of conversion numbers. In an interview, present the same symptoms without revealing the answer. Observe whether the candidate checks the actual event name and configuration before suggesting an additional budget. Google Analytics event naming guidelines
The fourth evidence consists of channel costs that can be reconciled
Ask how the agency calculates the cost of acquiring one reservation. Write advertising spend, media or service costs, commissions, promotions paid for by the property, and payment processing fees separately. Not all costs must go into one formula for every decision. Most importantly, the numerator and denominator are explained and the same cost is not calculated twice. Ask finance to determine the treatment for taxes and refunds.
Use a guest example who initially found the villa through an advertisement, then booked via phone. Ask the candidate to explain what is actually recorded and what is still an estimate. If the income is included in a channel's report, state the reason and limitations. The owner can request two views: results directly connected to transactions and results that still require confirmation. This method makes changes in assumptions visible in monthly decisions.
The fifth evidence is in the form of a vendor responsibility map
Ask the candidate to draw a simple flow from the room page to availability, payment, email confirmation, and reservation notes. Beside each transition, write down who has access to view the failure and who can fix it. Price changes may be in the hands of the revenue manager, while button labels become the responsibility of the website team. Ask who coordinates both if one guest request passes through multiple systems at once.
Submit an example of a room that appears available on the website but is taken when the guest proceeds to pay. Ask the candidate to create an incident report with the test date, room type, device, reproduction steps, and the person to be contacted. Payment number and guest identity are not required in the example shared in the interview forum. To see the scope of work at this handoff point, use Alpha booking engine integration explanation.
The sixth evidence is a plan to fairly compare the results
Ask how the candidate compares a campaign change to the appropriate period. If the number of rooms sold changes, new packages are available, or the hotel closes a wing of the building for renovation, the month-over-month revenue difference is difficult to read directly as an advertising impact. Request a proposal for a group of dates, inventory, and markets that are sufficiently comparable. Write special events in the reference period. Differences that cannot be explained should appear in the analysis notes.
Test with a simple scenario. A promotion increases the number of reservations but pushes many guests to choose a refundable rate. Ask when the results will be re-evaluated and what the reports look like after the guests complete their stay. If the candidate suggests a new change, ask them to specify the data that will change that decision. Showing willingness to discuss uncertainty helps the owner distinguish between changes that can be implemented now and experiments that still require observation.
The seventh evidence is in the form of a handover example, including if the contract ends
Request an example of a masked handover document. Note the property account list, change documentation, team access, metric definitions, open work notes, and how to export data. Ask what actions are covered in the routine cost and which require an additional order. If the agency relies on a booking engine provider or a separate design team, list the functional contact as well as the service hours they agree to themselves.
Invite operational staff to read the example without oral explanation from the candidate. Ask them to show who needs to be contacted when the room page has the wrong price at night. If several calls are needed to find the person in charge, mark the section of the document that needs clarification. Test also when the main personnel are on leave. The owner needs to know where to access data and how the work is continued during personnel changes or supplier changes.
Make a decision based on evidence after the presentation
Provide one line for each evidence with observed column, not yet available, and confirmation step. For evidence already shown, record what is seen and under what condition. For answers that are only promises, write down the required artifacts and delivery date. If two candidates offer different scopes, compare the same parts first then calculate the needs the hotel still has to fulfill through third parties.
Close the meeting with one initial task that has a clear deadline. For example, map the reservation path from the selected landing page to the payment record, then report the break points and propose testing for them. Agree on who approves the results, where to store evidence, and actions if access is not yet available. The decision to expand cooperation becomes easier when the hotel has seen how the candidate treats incomplete data, corrects errors, and answers the field team's questions.
As a final exercise, ask the candidate to show the report format when no reservations are recorded. The report may still include actual expenses, test dates, tracking status, and issues being investigated. Also include unanswered questions. The prospective partner who mentions a specific cause needs to demonstrate a test that differentiates that cause from other possibilities, such as out of stock or delayed transactions.
Then ask them to write down decisions that the owner can make at the end of the meeting. For example, approving testing on one payment path, assigning staff to check rates, or waiting for data after the stay period is over. Each decision needs to have an owner and a follow-up deadline. Save the decisions together with the interview materials so that when the final proposal comes, you can hold each candidate to the work they described and compare the proposed deadlines fairly.
Alpha Digital Hospitality Practice
Need a Google Ads and Direct Booking Audit for Your Property?
We audit OTA commission leakage, GA4 conversion tracking, and Google Ads connections to real hotel or villa reservations.
Related Alpha Digital Pages
Continue withDigital Marketing Bali
Explore all articles aboutDigital Marketing BaliMore from Alpha Digital