Alpha.
Monitor and keyboard on a wooden desk, with plants and a garden view through a round window.

Written by Alpha Digital Agency· · Updated

Agency Interview for Head of Digital Resort Group, Bali: How Well Do They Understand Direct Booking Economics?

Use this reservation example, expense account, and interview question to assess whether the agency proposal is reasonable for each resort's margin.


Digital Head's Question When Choosing an Agency

"As head of digital for a Bali resort group, how should I judge whether an agency understands direct booking economics?" This question can be tested with a reservation. Give the candidate one example of a completed stay, anonymize the guest's identity, then ask them to explain how much is left for the property after channel costs. If the candidate needs to see commission invoices, payment details, and promotion deductions before answering, note the data they request. From there, the head of digital can assess the depth of their analysis.

For groups managing resorts in Ubud and beach properties in southern Bali, start with property-level reports. Package sales with breakfast at one resort are not directly comparable to room-only sales at another resort. First agree on the definition of the period, room revenue, number of nights, currency, withholding tax, and reservation status. Ask the candidate to save that list of assumptions on a calculation sheet that the finance team can review.

During the interview session, hand over the sheet containing the empty advertising cost columns. Ask the candidate to mark which numbers need to be requested from marketing before filling in the acquisition cost columns. Ask them to indicate where the actual numbers will be entered, which assumptions can change, and what conclusions change if the payment contract is renewed.

Calculate contribution per completed stay

The following illustrative example uses made-up units so the logic is visible. One reservation for two nights brings in a room revenue of one hundred units. On the OTA channel, suppose the total distribution cost charged is fifteen units. Eighty-five units remain before accommodation operational costs. On the direct channel, for the same room rate and package, suppose processing cost is three units, acquisition is eight units, and guest benefit cost is two units. The direct channel contribution is eighty-seven units. The difference is two units for one reservation, not fifteen units.

We recalculate that example by changing just one assumption. When the direct acquisition cost becomes sixteen units and the other components remain, the direct contribution drops to seventy-nine units. The difference against the original OTA channel of positive two units becomes negative six units. This is an editorial simulation using fictional figures, not data from a resort. Repeat with values from the property invoice before selecting the campaign budget.

Calculations change when the direct reservation comes from brand search without additional ad spend, when the guest exchanges a more expensive facility, or when the agency allocates campaign spend in another way. Ask the candidate to write the software fixed cost on a separate line. Fixed cost becomes a consideration for the monthly investment decision. Try an additional exercise with made-up numbers. Reduce the contribution of eighty-seven units by one ten-unit subscription. The result is seventy-seven units. If the next expense column copies the same ten-unit subscription, the total written will be sixty-seven units. Mark both lines with the same made-up invoice number so the team can see the source of the difference.

Also ask if the guest will actually book via OTA if the direct site is unavailable. Channel switching is a hypothesis that needs to be tested. New orders have a different benchmark compared to old guest orders that previously regularly booked via phone. Separate new customers, returning customers, and customers that cannot be classified. Show the size of the unknown portion before using the report as the basis for adding the budget.

What is Direct Booking Economics and Why Agencies Must Understand

In this interview sheet, use the direct booking economics term for limited and calculable questions: what is the remaining room revenue per order after channel costs in the simulation above? If the candidate wants to estimate the value of the next guest visit, ask them to make an additional calculation with their own sources and assumptions. Save the result per order in a separate column so the team can still repeat the initial example.

Ask the agency to show the cost components from the property document. Commission rates can be traced to the contract and invoice, payment fees to the disbursement report, and marketing costs to the campaign invoice. For breakfast incentives, use the actual costs borne by the property according to the financial agreement. Breakfast prices sold to guests run into other calculations and can make the direct channel appear too expensive if used as actual cost.

Therefore, the agency building the custom booking engine must be able to clearly explain the break-even point. They are required to answer: how many direct bookings are needed per month so that the booking engine cost is cheaper than the OTA commission? If the agency cannot map this cost flow, they are not selling a business solution, but merely selling software.

Five interview questions for candidates

First, what is the contribution per completed stay on each channel? Provide two candidate examples with different durations and ask for an explanation of whether one night, one reservation, or one guest is used as the denominator. A satisfactory answer should be traceable back to the original number when finance opens the order.

Second, what happens if a guest cancels? Ask the candidate to draw up the order journey starting from the deposit payment until the fund return. Provide two lines of dummy data, one marked as check-in and one marked as cancelled. Ask the candidate to mark which line they input into the simulation, state the cost that has been charged in the example, and explain who on the finance team needs to verify that assumption.

Third, how do they separate additional sales from channel shifts? Ask for a comparison of properties or periods with similar characteristics. Fourth, what is done when a purchase is recorded in the reservation system but the campaign report does not recognize its source? The candidate needs to provide an unknown source category and a way to trace the cause, without sharing guest identity data to the marketing report.

Fifth, give the candidate an example of a holiday season when demand rises across all channels. Ask them to show reasons supporting the claim that a specific campaign contributed to the increase. Check whether they consider rate increases, local events, reopening of renovated rooms, and differences in stay duration. Each can affect results even if ad settings remain the same.

Evaluation Checklist: Signs an Agency Understands Direct Booking Economics

Bring the assessment sheet to the interview room. Use the question column, evidence shown, data owner, and items still to be checked. Note if the candidate shows one example of matching a reservation number to settlement. Note separately if they only promised that feature after the contract. In this way, colleagues in revenue, front office, and finance can compare the answers they can verify themselves.

Ask the revenue team to check discount treatment and room type changes, the reservations team to check order status changes, and finance to check the actual costs paid. The Digital Head can then see whether their marketing strategy can be measured using the data that is indeed available. If a prospective provider requests a full guest profile export for a task that requires a random reservation number, request an example file with minimum columns.

For a vendor case study, request a comparison period, number of properties, and business context in an anonymized form. If one candidate brings a city hotel example and another brings a resort example, write whether each package includes dinner, transfers, or rooms only. If the vendor finds it difficult to share client data that is confidential, give them the same sample data to all candidates and evaluate the quality of the work from there.

Common Head of Digital Mistakes When Choosing a Booking Engine Agency

To evaluate a portfolio, select one example from the candidate's presentation. Request two documents that can be checked separately: the design presentation evaluated by the marketing team and the cost reconciliation sample evaluated by the finance team. Note any open questions about each document before discussing the budget.

Give the candidate a second sample with two fictional reservations whose values are the same. Request two different transaction identifiers, then add a duplicate to one of the confirmations. Ask the candidate to explain how they distinguish the two original orders from the repeated confirmation. Google documents deduplication of purchases with the same transaction_id and suggests a unique identifier for each order. Use numbers that do not contain the guest identity. Google Guide for transaction identifiers

Check also whether the report allocates campaign manager costs to each property consistently. If the regional team pays one contract for multiple locations, determine the allocation basis at the beginning of the period. Show results before and after allocation so the general manager can distinguish local transaction performance from central overhead.

Measurement Plan: How the Head of Digital Measures Booking Engine Success

Alpha team audit notes on May 21 show why this question is important [source: Alpha conversion event configuration audit, May 21, 2026]. On one hospitality property checked, the configured purchase event was not recorded during the audit period. The initial form event, prospect, and conversation events were actually recorded. The team compared the list of events set as conversion with the list of events actually recorded for the same period. Findings were limited to that measurement. The report did not prove that the property lost orders or did not receive payment. In the interview, ask the vendor to differentiate the recorded events from the order values already matched with finance.

At the beginning of the meeting, prepare a budget sheet and a transaction list for the period being discussed. The first step is to establish a baseline: the percentage of direct bookings vs. OTA this month, the average ADR, and the total monthly OTA commission. You can use the calculation formulas discussed in the beginning of this article to obtain accurate baseline figures.

Match purchase and refund events in analytics with transactions recorded in the reservation system. The Google ecommerce documentation explains purchase and refund events and the use of transaction_id. Save internal order numbers that do not contain a guest name. Check the sample when two transactions have the same value so the team can distinguish random numbers from identifier matches. Google Analytics ecommerce guide

Before adding the budget, make a written decision per property. State the changes tested, the comparison period used, who checks the final invoice, and the conditions that will cause the decision to be canceled. If data is limited, display the number of orders along with the total value and avoid concluding that a small difference represents the entire market.

Document brought to the next meeting

Bring an example of a completed stay order, one cancellation, one partial refund, and one ad invoice. Blur the guest's identity. Ask the candidate to return the calculation sheet and open-ended question notes. The most valuable explanation often appears when their numbers differ from the finance notes and they are able to trace the difference back to the original document.

Alpha Digital Hospitality Practice

Need a Google Ads and Direct Booking Audit for Your Property?

We audit OTA commission leakage, GA4 conversion tracking, and Google Ads connections to real hotel or villa reservations.

Related Alpha Digital Pages

Continue withBooking Engine

Explore all articles aboutBooking Engine

More from Alpha Digital

Related Articles

Call
WhatsApp
Email